Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Al Duncan's avatar

Remarkable research and very well written piece, Leah.

From a personal point of lack of knowledge, those horrific attacks on Iran just felt astounding, as in wtaf.

I never imagined the utilisation of such extreme force could be based on flimsy, disputable evidence.

You’ve described, by gathering factual information, the political manoeuvring which has taken place. And we wonder why World Wars happen……

Something is rotten in the state of the Western World.

Expand full comment
Malcolm Lumsden Clark Smith's avatar

For 75 years much of the world has lived with Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD). One has to ask why Israel is not willing to live with it. Iran is no more willing to be destroyed in a nuclear war than any other nation. The reason is of course that Israel is determined to dominate and intimidate other countries in the region at her will. And the United States supports Israel's regional hegemony.

Nuclear weapons are a risk to the future of mankind, but Israeli claims that Iran is a rogue state and cannot be trusted are utterly hypocritical. The last time Iran was a peaceful democratic state was just before her government was overthrown with British and Americans assistance in 1953. She has a right to be hostile to the West, and a right to support the Palestinians. If there is a rogue state it is Israel, the state responsible for the Palestinian Holocaust.

One of the antisemitic tropes is that Jewish people cannot be trusted because they have split loyalties. However, here we have the Jewish IAEA's Director General apparently colluding with Israel. Another example of possible split loyalties are the two senior Jewish journalists in the Middle Eastern division of the BBC who are accused of pro-Israeli bias. Not only do individuals have questionable loyalties, but, more powerful in their support of Israel are the Jewish groups in the US, UK, Australia, Canada and Europe . These groups, such as IAPAC have had profound effects on American politics; pushing the US to do the bidding of Netanyahu. In the UK Jewish groups have been responsible for the political assassination of Jeremy Corbyn and giving financial support to UK Cabinet Members. Were these people simply attempting to improve relations between their respective countries and Israel this would not be an issue in times of peace. Were Israel a nation that follows international law, this would not be an issue. Were Israel a country that had not brutally suppressed and dispossessed Palestinians, this would not be an issue. Were Israel not a country guilty of genocide, ethnic cleansing and other crimes against humanity, this would not be an issue. But Israel is a brutal, dangerous rogue state, and it is an issue. A sensitive issue, but nevertheless an important issue.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts